When you’re handing requested items to a questgiver (Bess Mackenzie or Tom Shepherd, for example), make sure you have all of them! If you’re handing in items, and you realize that you don’t have all of them, click the red X and back out, you’ll be able to complete the mission successfully later on, when you do have all the required items. There is an issue with questgiver NPCs and incomplete requirements: When a player hands in half of the required items, the NPC accepts them but does not give credit for them. So please do not hit OK until you’ve given the questgiver all the requested items! Continue reading...
Bumping this to make sure it's known to all Islanders. Please do not hit OK and give a questgiver half of the required items!